• Desserts

    All deserts are made from scratch in our kitchen. Prepared fresh… Every day!
    • Bring On The Chocolate
      $7
      60
      Chocolate at its best. A chocolate fudge nut brownie stuffed with chocolate ice cream, chocolate sauce, whipped cream, nuts and topped with a cherry. Indulge yourself.
    • Ice Cream
      $3
      Two scoops of old fashioned ice cream in a dish. PLAIN $3 | WITH TOPPING $5
    • New York Style Cheescake
      $8
      The original Bay Street Tower of Power cheesecake topped with your choice of strawberry, raspberry, or blueberry sauce.
    • Key Lime Pie
      $7
      30
      Cool and light, a favourite in Florida and here at the Bay Street.
    • Deep Fried Cheesecake
      $7
      30
      Classic cheesecake wrapped in a flour tortilla, deep fried, dusted with cinnamon sugar and served over a raspberry coulee.
    • Old Fashioned Apple Crisp
      $6
      Our own house recipe. Tender apples kissed with maple syrup and covered in a rich crunchy topping. PLAIN $6 | A LA MODE $7
    • Carrot Cake
      $7
      Layer upon layer of dark moist carrot cake finished with a creamy smooth icing.
    • Deep Fried Ice Cream
      $8
      A delicious treat. Crisp and warm on the outside, cold and tasty on the inside.
    • Georgian Bay Mudslide
      $7
      60
      Homemade Mocha ice cream on a chocolate crust, with whipped cream, hot fudge, caramel and almonds.
    • Deep Fried Mars Bar
      $7
      Deep frying a chocolate favourite creates a crazily good tasting dessert. Served with caramel and chocolate sauce on top.
    • Deep Fried Marsmallows
      $7
      60
      Two large deep fried marshmallows & graham crackers dipped in batter and fried just long enough to crisp up the outside with a gooey middle. We top it off with chocolate and butterscotch topping. Makes for a great treat.